ASUS ROG Scar 16

• Commenters noted the laptop's sleek design, commenting, "Looks hawt tho."
• The laptop is described as expensive, with one user mentioning, "Looking great but certainly not cheap!"
• One commenter expressed excitement for the product, saying, "that looks awesome, I bet costs a fortune."
• Concerns were raised about the hinges being fragile and a suggestion was made to use one large hinge.
• Users requested benchmarks for performance comparison with other models like the Razer Blade 16.
• Comparisons were made between different versions (5080 vs. 5090), highlighting potential cost-saving opportunities.
• Some users were eager for benchmark results such as the TimeSpy benchmark and tests for coil whine.
• Requests were made to check for missing ROPs using GPU-Z and inquiries were made about the presence of OLED or mini-LED screens.
• A variety of comments praised the laptop's features, expressed curiosity about internals, and shared personal experiences with purchasing gaming laptops.

Pros

• Sleek design
• High-quality display
• Benchmark performance
• Wide range of configurations available
• Potential cost-saving opportunities

Cons

• Fragile hinges
• High price point
• Concerns about possible design flaws
• Mixed feedback on customer support

ASUS ROG Scar 18

• Users had mixed experiences with the laptop, with some praising it as the best they've owned and others facing issues like unresponsive keyboards, display problems, and driver issues.
• Some users pointed out potential solutions like installing G-Helper to address certain issues.
• There were comparisons to the Scar 17 model, comments expressing disappointment in ASUS quality, and suggestions to update drivers to resolve problems.
• A user shared a photo of their laptop and expressed regret at missing out on a deal for a different product.
• The struggle with NVIDIA drivers causing black screen issues was mentioned.
• The challenges of dealing with laptop problems and criticisms of ASUS service were expressed.

Pros

• Quality build and performance (for some users)
• Positive experiences with Scar 17 models
• Potential for resolution via driver updates
• Mixed satisfaction with the laptop's features

Cons

• Issues reported with the keyboard, display, and connectivity
• Criticisms of ASUS customer service
• Challenges with NVIDIA drivers leading to black screen problems

It's important to consider various user experiences and feedback when evaluating the ASUS ROG Scar 16 and Scar 18 laptops. Each product has its strengths and weaknesses as indicated by Reddit commentary and reviews.