Ranking of American Horror Story Seasons

Asylum

• Pros: "The ending of Asylum...probably the best ending of any of the seasons in its entirety."
• Cons: "Violet is just annoying to me. And the season as a whole is too slow."

Murder House

• Pros: "Murder House is probably my favorite too."
• Cons: "More classical and has some themes that may not be appealing to everyone."

1984

• Pros: "I love 1984."
• Cons: "Many people dislike this season."

Coven

• Pros: "Coven is probably my favorite."
• Cons: Some issues related to racism and casual racism in the storytelling.

Roanoke

• Pros: "Roanoke is the best one."
• Cons: The second half might not be as strong as the first.

Apocalypse

• Pros: "Apocalypse is really good, especially as a follow up from Coven."
• Cons: Not in everyone's top favorites.

Hotel

• Pros: "Ranked Hotel higher after rewatching."
• Cons: Some find it boring; has some enjoyable moments.

Freak Show

• Pros: "Freak Show is the best one!!"
• Cons: Some find it underrated, but not in their top picks.

Cult

• Pros: "Cult is one of my favorites."
• Cons: Many find it unsettling and filled with gratuitous violence.

NYC

• Pros: "I liked it, was good."
• Cons: Some find it didn't meet their expectations.

Red Tide

• Pros: "Macaulay Culkin!!! Super fun."
• Cons: The finale didn't appeal to everyone.

Double Feature

• Pros: "The first part of Double Feature with the New England Vampires is good."
• Cons: The young TikTok influencer cast may not resonate with everyone.

Overall Best Horror Stories

• Asylum
• Murder House
• 1984
• Coven
• Roanoke
• Apocalypse

Best Horror Movies

• Tucker & Dale Vs. Evil
• Shaun of the Dead
• What We Do In The Shadows
• Cabin in the Woods
• Death Becomes Her
• Evil Dead 2

These summaries provide a comprehensive look at the Reddit user comments for the best American Horror Story seasons and horror movies.