Summary of Reddit Comments Related to Query "https youtu be hlxt yq e0gcg si 5z8ky kk cx zc0v dx"

Overall Opinion on the Comics Issue

The quality of the comics has been criticized for a decline, especially in later issues.
The timeline inconsistencies and illogical plot points have been highlighted, such as Vader's involvement with constructing Death Star II conflicting with the timeline of ESB and ROTJ.
The introduction of new, seemingly pointless characters like Palpatine's 'assassin' has been negatively received.
The storytelling involving Vader controlling a tentacle creature and other elements were seen as confusing and poorly executed, leading to doubts about the ability of external materials to redeem the Sequel trilogy.

- Operation Cinder and Palpatine's motives post-TROS have been described as ridiculous and confusing.

The role of the First Order in relation to the Final Order was questioned, with suggestions that they served no purpose.
The portrayal of Vader has been criticized for making him appear ineffectual and deviating from his character in previous Disney material.

The negative impact that tie-ins to the Sequel Trilogy had on the comics was emphasized.
The portrayal of events in the comics was seen as undermining key moments in Return of the Jedi.
Questions were raised about the decisions made by characters like Vader, Palpatine, and Luke in the context of the comic storyline.

Users praised the detailed analysis and effort put into the post summarizing the comics' issues.
Some users expressed disillusionment with the direction of the Star Wars franchise post-2015, citing issues like retcons, bad writing, and inconsistencies.
A range of reactions from frustration to amusement were observed in response to the comic storyline and tie-ins to the Sequel Trilogy.
Positive feedback and appreciation were also given for other non-related comments and posts in the Reddit thread.