Summary of Reddit Comments on "Netgear Nighthawk"

Pros and Cons of Netgear Nighthawk:

Pros:

• Easy setup without the need for a mobile app for initial installation.
• Good speeds and reliability in some cases, with better performance than ISP-provided routers.
• Decent value for the price compared to other options.

Cons:

• Issues with firmware updates leading to router malfunctions and potential bricking after updates.
• Some features may be locked behind a paid subscription, limiting functionality.
• Limited support from Netgear after a short period, with paid support plans required for assistance.
• Concerns about data collection and metrics sent back to Netgear servers without clear visibility or control for users.
• Lack of OpenWRT support due to Broadcom chipset.
• Some users experienced packet loss, random reboots, and other performance issues after several months of use.

Advice and Recommendations:

• Consider alternatives like Unifi routers or other brands for better long-term support and performance.
• Avoid Netgear Nighthawk due to potential issues and lack of support.
• Invest in a separate modem/router setup over a combo device for better control and performance.

Actions to Take:

• Perform a factory reset on the modem/router and set it up from scratch.
• Contact the ISP for troubleshooting support.
• Check signal levels, connections, and splitters to ensure proper setup.
• Consider replacing the Netgear Nighthawk due to end-of-life status and potential issues.

Overall, the comments highlight mixed experiences with the Netgear Nighthawk routers, including concerns about support, reliability, and performance issues. It is recommended to explore other brands and models for better long-term satisfaction and performance.