Summary of Reddit Comments on "pod etsy"

Print-On-Demand (POD) Platforms

• Printify: Users find Printify simple to use and recommend it for creating designs, focusing on quality, and ease of use.
  • "Stuck with Printify because it's simple and lets me focus on creating."
• Customcat, Teelaunch, ShineOn: These US-based suppliers are praised for their automation and connection to online stores for POD businesses.
  • "I used Printify for a while, but now switched to Customcat, Teelaunch and ShineOn."
• Gooten: Users did not have a great experience with the platform, finding it clunky compared to others like Printify.
  • "Started with Gooten and found their UX clunky, switched to Printify for a smoother experience."

POD on Etsy

• Etsy and POD: Etsy is used for POD by many, although some express concerns about low profit margins, high competition, and the impact on genuine handmade items.
  • "Printful worked well for me, with good product quality, but Etsy Ads are a waste of money for POD shops."
• Printful: Users appreciate Printful for its product quality and smooth integration with Etsy.
  • "Found Printful's products consistently good, especially for apparel and accessories."
• Etsy Ads: Some users caution against using Etsy Ads for POD shops due to low margins and high competition.
  • "Etsy Ads seem to cost me $0.20-0.40 a click, it's abysmal for cost per sale."

Profit and Sustainability

• Profitability: Concerns are raised about the profitability of POD businesses on Etsy, highlighting the need for realistic expectations and careful budgeting.
  • "Revenue doesn’t include ads, fees, taxes, or production costs, resulting in lower profits."
• Sustainability: Some users question the sustainability of POD on Etsy as a full-time income source, citing challenges with cost-effectiveness and time investment.
  • "This model isn’t sustainable for a full-time job, with an hourly rate of $10.60 without income tax."

Other Insights

• ArrowGiftCoLtd: Operates differently from traditional POD shops by printing in-house, leading to potentially higher profits.
  • "Arrow Gift Co prints in-house and ships products directly, avoiding third-party fees."
• AI in Designs: AI is mentioned as a tool for creating unique designs but is not a guarantee of sales success.
  • "AI makes it easier to create designs, but success depends on more than just design creation."
• Platform Comparisons: Users stress the importance of samples, customization, and clear communication in selecting the right POD platform for their business.
  • "Ordering samples first is recommended to check quality and shipping speed."

Overall, the comments provide a mix of experiences and insights into using various POD platforms for Etsy, highlighting challenges such as low profit margins, competition, and the importance of careful budgeting and realistic expectations for sustainable business growth.