Summary of Reddit Comments on "purbaya mentri keuangan"

Purbaya as a Finance Minister

Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa has been appointed as the new Finance Minister, replacing Sri Mulyani Indrawati.
Some find his statements controversial and question his experience and effectiveness.
People are divided on his demeanor, some finding it casual and acceptable, while others see it as lacking professionalism.
There are concerns about his performance given his lack of experience as a minister.
Some are critical of the public's quick judgment before giving him a chance to prove himself.

Pros and Cons of Purbaya as Finance Minister

Pros:

Purbaya has a background in finance and experience working in the market.
He expressed determination to improve economic growth and stabilize the financial market.
Some believe in giving him the benefit of the doubt and supporting him in his new role.
His tenure might bring new strategies and potentially positive outcomes for the economy.

Cons:

Concerns about potentially inflating the economy and the risks associated with increased credit lending.
Some fear his policies may lead to inflation and pose risks for the economy.
Questions are raised regarding the effectiveness of his plans to stimulate economic growth and provide relief to the people.
Skepticism about the allocation of funds and the impact on market stability.

Comparison to Sri Mulyani

Sri Mulyani Indrawati received praise for her competence and dedication to her role as Finance Minister.
Some express sadness over her departure and highlight her contribution as a competent minister.
There are concerns about potential differences in leadership style between Sri Mulyani and Purbaya.
Sri Mulyani's departure is viewed with mixed emotions, reflecting her impact and dedication to the country.
Sri Mulyani's effectiveness and professionalism are contrasted with initial skepticism about Purbaya.

Financial Policies and Criticisms

Criticisms about policies to increase credit lending and the potential consequences.
Concerns about mismanagement of funds and risks associated with stimulating credit growth.
Questions about the distribution of funds and the impact on different economic sectors.
Skepticism about the effectiveness of short-term measures to stimulate economic growth.
Comparison to past policies and their outcomes in addressing economic challenges.

In summary, there are mixed reactions to Purbaya's appointment as Finance Minister, with concerns raised about his policies and effectiveness compared to his predecessor, Sri Mulyani Indrawati. Some are hopeful for positive outcomes, while others express doubts about the impact of his economic strategies. The comments reflect a range of perspectives on the future of Indonesia's economy under Purbaya's leadership.