Summary of Reddit Comments on "SAP Data Extraction"

SAP ERP Implementation Challenges

SAP ERP implementations often face challenges with schedule and cost overruns, as noted by a user who mentioned that most implementations do not go as planned.
A user with 15 years of experience implementing SAP solutions highlighted the common scenario where promises made during the sales pitch do not match the actual delivery capabilities, leading to project delays and budget expansions.
The trustworthiness of SAP in safeguarding client data was emphasized, stating that SAP cannot compromise client trust due to strong NDA policies.

SAP ERP Implementation Criticism

An SAP implementation expert pointed out reasons for failed implementations, such as poor communication between clients and consultants, unrealistic expectations, and the complexity of adapting standard systems.
Another user suggested that external consultants play a crucial role in understanding SAP, highlighting that consulting firms like Accenture, Deloitte, and PwC have insider knowledge.
It was indicated that overcomplicating issues like tracking truck geolocation may not be necessary to assess the success of an ERP implementation, suggesting looking into the experience and knowledge of consultants instead.

Data Extraction from SAP

Various methods were suggested for extracting data from SAP, including using tools like HVR, SAP Data Services (BODS), Fivetran, OData services, and Apache Hop.
Recommendations included leveraging SAP's native tools, ETL platforms, event streaming platforms, integration platforms, and specialized tools for data extraction.
Users also proposed automating data extraction through VBA, VBScript, Power Query, and using custom CDS views or reports built by IT departments.
Suggestions were made to involve Data Engineers for ETL processes, creating custom CDS views, or utilizing t-codes like SQVI in SAP for data extraction.

SAP Migration to Workday

A user shared their experience with SAP HR to Workday migration, emphasizing the importance of defining clear cut-off dates, reviewing processes, and ensuring data accuracy during the transition.

This summary provides insights into the challenges of SAP ERP implementations, critiques of the implementation process, methods for data extraction from SAP, and considerations for migrating data from SAP to platforms like Workday.