Last updated: April 26, 2025 at 01:43 AM
Tarte Mascara Summary
Reddit Comments Overview
- Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions: Preferred over Tarte by some users due to smudge-proof and easy removal.
- Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions vs Tarte: Some find Tarte clumps easier than Thrive, while others like the neat tubing of Tarte.
- Blinc Mascara: Tarte is considered nice and neat compared to Blinc.
- Hourglass Mascara: Some users prefer Hourglass over Tarte for easier removal and less smudging.
- Caliray Tubing Mascara: Favored by users with oily eyelids, but some find it flakes and prefer other brands.
- Caliray vs Tarte Tubing Mascara: While Caliray has good wear, Tarte is favored for easier removal and a bit more lengthening.
- CA-Based Mascara Brands: Tarte is available in Canada, while Caliray is easier to find there.
- Elf Lash XTNDR: A cheaper alternative to Thrive, but not as lengthening or volumizing.
- Maybelline Sky High Mascara: An affordable tubing mascara option with good performance.
- KVD Beauty Full Sleeve Mascara: A highly recommended tubing mascara by some users.
- Nudestix Waterproof Mascara: Pricier but long-wearing and non-irritating.
- Merits Tubing Mascara: A mid-range tubing mascara priced at $26.
- Kevin Aucoin Mascara: Known for being the best tubing mascara but not available at Sephora anymore.
Pros and Cons
- Tarte Mascara:
- Pros: Neat tubing, lengthening effect, good brush, and staying power.
- Cons: Can clump, difficulty washing off, may flake.
- Alternatives:
- Thrive: Smudge-proof and easy to remove, preferred by some over Tarte.
- Hourglass: Preferred for easier removal and less smudging compared to Tarte.
- Other Brands:
- Caliray: Good for oily lids but may flake, preferred by some over Tarte.
- Elf Lash XTNDR: Cheaper alternative, not as lengthening as others.
- General:
- Some users found Tarte XL version clumpier and harder to work with than the original.
- Preferences vary among users regarding clumping, flaking, and ease of removal for different tubing mascaras.
This summary provides an overview of Reddit comments related to Tarte mascara, comparisons with other brands, pros, and cons of different products for easy comparison based on user experiences and preferences.
